Monday, March 19, 2018

Non-core Post 2 – The Black-ish and NFL Debate

I stumbled across this article on ABC shelving an episode of Black-ish over the national anthem and NFL debate that was supposed to be aired the last week of February. I found it to be an interesting article to debate upon because it touches on many things we have discussed in the past few weeks and the representation of race and gender in primetime television. While the official reason given by ABC is 'creative differences', it pales against the topics that were to be discussed within the episode – an argument over the rights of athletes to kneel during the performance of the national anthem at football game being a major plot point. Considering that Black-ish has become a highly rated show that has been praised for raising multiple political and social issues, what does this mean in the tug-of-war between studios and showrunners? I would love to discuss this in class tomorrow.

You can read the article here – http://variety.com/2018/tv/news/abc-shelves-blackish-political-1202722980/

Core Post 3 – Week 10 – Postfeminism and the Politics of Race

The readings for this week gripped my attention from start to finish. Each of the authors discusses the issue of postfeminism and how it has become a dual argument in its representation in popular culture. Banet-Wiser goes into detail on the shift feminism has taken, McRobbie follows a similar trajectory into the deconstruction of feminism into postfeminism and its implications, while Butler delves deeper into the problematic representations of race and ethnicity that postfeminism has given birth to.

Considering the two shows we saw in our last class with respect to this week’s topic, I found the juxtaposition interesting. While Sex and the City definitely normalizes the issue of the feminist stance, Insecure had a more layered approach to it along with topics of race as can be seen when the lead character rants about her white coworkers debating about the predominantly black affluent neighborhood they’re in. Additionally, both shows feature multiple female characters who interestingly are personifications of the different definitions of feminism discussed throughout the readings. In particular, I was really fascinated by the jump between femininity and feminism that most of them grow through – the ‘ordinary housewife appeal’ to the ‘independent career woman’.

Another point that stood out was in the Banet-Wiser reading where she discusses the shift gender representations have taken, from being racially specific to universally appealing or even ambiguously “diverse”. She uses Dora the Explorer has an example and elaborates on it. But I think there are multiple shows that reiterate her point – from the Mindy Project, Grey’s Anatomy or even American Horror Story: Coven. All these shows give us a powerful dose of ‘girl power’, with layered and strong characters and storylines, but their racial and ethnic representations have been crafted for universal appeal, with sometimes-stereotypical characteristics. But that doesn’t take away from their postfeminist appeal because as McRobbie discuses, feminism must be dismantled in order for postfeminism to be integrated into popular culture. 

Core post #4 - Living in a Post-World and I am a Post-Girl


Post-feminist, post-colonial, post-structural, post-racial – sometimes our world seems so post-everything, I am not sure what this means for the current politics of identity scholarship. I also found it fascinating how dated these articles feel even though they were written within the last decade. Change has been brewing, and the #metoo and #timesup movements are reshaping our cultural landscape. Broadly, when reading these articles, I felt a sense of anxiety that current “post-feminsts” have neglected and ignored past struggles - as if, women have always had agency and are “leaning in” because they want to – not because they are now able to. And while I agree with Butler, Banet-Weiser, and McRobbie’s assessments, specifically in regard to media representations like Bridget Jones or Sex and the City, I am not entirely sure if this was reflected in non-mediated culture. I think the media and consumer culture of Girl Power was more aspirational than actual. As a non-scientific example/ anecdote, I was taking a Super Shuttle home from the airport yesterday. The driver dictated where we should sit based on the order of our drop-offs. The way the seating arrangement worked, in the back row there was a 50 some-year-old man tightly sandwiched between two USC undergrad girls. One of the girls said, “I don’t know if there is room, but I guess we will make it work.” The man replied, to the shuttle at large, “Its okay by me! I’m in a tight squeeze between two young ladies!” If this happened a couple of years ago, I would have laughed it off. In a postfeminist mentality I would have decided he was just being funny and didn’t mean anything by it. Now, because of our current culture, I turned around, looked him in the eye and said “really?!” in a shameful manner. I wanted to say more, but also didn’t want to start a quarrel in the Super Shuttle. If I had been one of the girls sitting next to him, I would have been asked to be moved. The point is, I don’t think we were ever postfeminist, but perhaps we wanted to be, or wished we were. McRobbie explains how “riualistic denunciation occurs when feminism is acknowledged but in a trivialized fashion, shelved as something that may have been useful in the past but is clearly out of date in today’s world” (as cited in Banet-Weiser, p. 207).  I agree with the readings, in that feminism was not out of date, just wistfully ignored.

The notion of race in regard to postfemism is an interesting theme throughout the readings. In true intersectional fashion, we cannot separate gender inequality from racial inequality, as the two are constantly reaffirming each other. However, in a consumer environment, Banet-Weiser explains how “these two identity categories – race as a “flava” and girl power- function together in the current media environment to produce categories of identity that are defined by ambiguity rather than specificity, ambivalence rather than political certainty” (Banet-Weiser, p. 203).  It is as though race is present but not fully explored. This feels to me like quintessential cultural appropriation – taking and profiting off of marginalized cultures without giving full homage to its origins.  I am wondering what the goal should be and what it should look like? If “relations of power are indeed made and re-made within texts of enjoyment and rituals of relaxation and abandonment” (McRobbie, p. 262), is there a way to rewrite this? Will there always be this kind of power dynamic regarding race and gender in our media representations? McRobbie and Banet-Weiser’s discussion speaks in conversation with Bulter. She states that, “the versatility of postfeminism functions as a double-edged sword with regard to women of color: on the one hand, it allows nonwhite women to participate in its deployment and enjoy its rewards, albeit in narrowly circumscribed ways; on the other, it works to conceal the underlying power relations that reproduce hegemonic ideas about race, gender, sexuality, and class” (Butler). I think this quotation is a strong example of the issue at hand, and one, that even in this post-postfeminist/ #metoo period, is still problematic. And while I enjoyed Butler’s piece, I did take issue with the fact that she specifically wanted to employ and intersectional lens, but framed her work in terms of Foucault and never once cited Patricia Hill Collins. This demonstrates how even in media critique, we are subject to hegemonic power structures that render race and gender (specifically the intersection of both) invisible.

I am interested to see what television will be growing out of our current #metoo era. Banet-Weiser states that, “Nickelodeon is widely lauded for its efforts to champion girls in what has been a historically male-dominated landscape” (Banet-Weiser, p. 202). Only a few days ago I read about the Clarissa Explains it All reboot, where Melissa Joan Heart will be playing the mom. How will this reboot embrace gender representations and racial identities?

Sunday, March 18, 2018

Core Post #3


Beyond the tight interlocutory connections between our three texts on postfeminism, there are a number of ways in which this grouping of readings intersects with critical discussions of concern in previous weeks. I am thinking in particular of Banet-Weiser’s citations of work by Herman Gray and her move of connecting critiques of postfeminism with a critique of postracial ideology (central in, of course, Esposito’s critique of <em>Ugly Betty</em>). Butler, meanwhile, is most explicit in drawing out connections between a postfeminist “sensibility” and formations of neoliberal governmentality (central in our readings on reality TV). And both Banet-Weiser and Butler are, of course, very much in conversation with McRobbie, who I now understand to be a major voice, at least in media studies, in conversations about things “postfeminist” – a term with which I was not really familiar before seeing it on this syllabus (though it does seem to at least ring a bell from my engagements with feminist journalism).

As Harry’s post suggests, an attempt to bolster one’s understanding of this term via Wikipedia may raise more questions than it answers. But sticking to the accounts offered in these readings, I find Butler’s explication most clarifying. Following Rosalind Gill, she argues that “rather than being understood as an epistemological perspective, an historical shift, or (simply) a backlash against feminism, postfeminism should be conceived of as a sensibility that characterizes an ever-increasing number of popular forms,” (43-4). While Butler uses the term “sensibility” in conjunction with popular forms/texts in particular, I think we could extend this out to thinking about how ideological postfeminism (and Butler does hold that it is “a contemporary gender ideology” [41]) becomes operationalized through subjects as a form of self-governance. The forms and imperatives of self-governance at work here of course go beyond the adoption of a “sensibility.” But I find a weak term such as this compelling for thinking about how “postfeminism” might manifest in everyday life and gestures, especially since I’m not sure whether “postfeminist” has ever been a widely applied descriptor—which is not to say that I’m unconvinced by these authors’ discussions of diffuse, pervasive cultural repudiations of feminist politics. 

But, then, of course, there is the present moment. The extent to which the widespread dismissal of feminism among young women that McRobbie describes has shifted over the relatively brief span since the time of her writing, or even over the briefer span since the 2013 publication of Butler’s piece, is striking. In a super obvious example, BeyoncĂ©'s use of text reading "feminist" in performances in 2016 and sampling of Chimamanda Ngozie Adichie's TED Talk in the track "Flawless" (2016) stand out to me as bellwether moments in the popularization of a, say, “post-postfeminist” sensibility that we might read as a major condition of possibility for the "#MeToo moment" and other present-day popular mobilizations against forms of patriarchal power. But then, in I guess a Gitlin-ish whine, perhaps this all just points to the extent to which feminism(s) are always imbricated with commodity feminism(s).


A (Slightly) Satiric Dialogue with Post-Feminist Scholarship (Core Post 3)

In the mire of the recent exposure of overt sexual assault in Hollywood and the #metoo movement, this week's readings which situate and deconstruct Post-Feminism, for me, created an interesting dialogue in terms of personal responsibility, women's coalitions, and modern constructions of femininity. In reading McRobbie, Banet-Weiser, and Butler, I questioned my own identity as a modern, young, white, compulsory heterosexual woman forming my sense of subjectivity in a neo-liberal, corporatist, consumer economy. I now even question the pedagogical function behind the aesthetics of Dora the Explorer. Am I caught in a rigid spectrum of "Barbie" versus "Boss Bitch," doomed to be reduced and dismissed no matter my identification? To the extent that I am a more awakened woman because of these readings remains to be seen.

However, I couldn't quite help but feel annoyed during my readings, as if I was being "mansplained" by feminist scholarship, victimized by being told that my post-feminist existence cruelly distorts my worldview. Such distortion thereby causes the chains of oppression, those very chains that previous waves of feminism fought so hard to dent/rust/sever, such distortion causes them to insidiously strengthen. As these chains bind me, post-feminist jargon allays me with the impression that these chains have been permanently destroyed, now a subject of ancient history. Can't I see? My expression of femininity, the degree of my sense of sex-positive empowerment and liberation, even my own achievements have been internalized into the market, only to be marketed back at me just to propel me to "yas qween" GET that lifestyle lift, GET those power pant suits, GET that degree without no man! The post-feminist consumer rhetoric reinforces that I am a modern woman, empowered rather than structurally oppressed, no longer a part of the commune of self-proclaimed victims of the patriarchy. I overcame the patriarchy in my own way, through my own lifestyle choices, through my own success. I pulled myself up from my Manolo Blahnik bootstraps and I'll be damned if privileged women of the academy, who espouse that, you know, despite its exclusivity, second-wave feminism was really onto something in its collective political banner of "womanhood," tell me otherwise! Little do they know... I'm with it. I get the joke behind commercialized objectification. I understand that perhaps my current status is because of the efforts of those who came before me, but... did they have to be so pushy? And, before we start throwing out Ally McBeal and her weird CGI biological-clock-is-ticking dancing baby as proof of white-washed post-feminism, let's look at some of the top figures in pop culture consumption: Rihanna, Beyonce, the Kardashians - note how almost all are female and non-white! But, alas, these women and their sense of success, liberation, and expressions are all lies; they are simply pawns in the cynical, neo-liberal, post-feminist, post-racial landscape, reinforcing the structures of oppression which they supposedly, allegedly worked so hard to overcome.

[End satiric dialogue]

There were several revelations that I conceded to in the readings. The neo-liberal idea of personal responsibility and self-regulation and their very strong causal ties to notions of merit and success are ingrained, in my fervent belief, into millennial psychology, specifically younger members, our very students, whose sense of self-worth is inextricably linked to their curricular performance. While each scholar deconstructs the proverbial Times Magazine question of "Is Feminism Dead?" and connects it the tenet of Post-Feminism that feminism is an easily identified, cogent moment of history that has ended, I found that laced within this uncovering of revisionist, fallacious post-feminist historicity was a certain propagation of blame. Perhaps previous notions of feminism are dead because of post-feminist women. While these scholars assert that feminism is still ubiquitous, though in myriad forms, they also contend that among the female majority (i.e. among white women) "feminist" is a dirty word.I found that apt in my own relationship to feminism. I consider myself a (quiet) feminist, but the extent to which I identify with the broad movement of feminism remains is less asserted in my worldview. It takes a man to say that he is a feminist to suddenly restore credibility to the label. Post-feminism renders the term feminist and its political and social implications empty. Thus, post-feminism, while it re-worked feminism as a thing of the past, we as post-feminist women claiming that we understand the joke and relish in its satire rather than outwardly deploring it, are allowing patriarchal, neo-liberal post-feminist myth to quell overarching feminist activism.

So, when Butler asks if Post-Feminism is for white girls only, I had to agree on some level. Second-wave feminism certainly originated out of planes of privilege, the outrage of women making 78 cents to every dollar a man earns fails to recognize the racial implications of gendered wage disparities. Intersectional feminism certainly serves minority women, and hopefully, transgendered women, with fights and struggles that elude white, middle-class (heterosexual) women such as myself, and because these classified and racialized struggles that intersect the similar gender struggles that are seen, by many white women, as overcome, we can undercut new forms of feminist activism. To frame the feminist struggle within history as a generational struggle, I find, apt - it echoes the inner turmoil of liberal parties and institutions in which new ideas and forms of liberalism clash with previous conceptions (think of the current Democratic Party).

Still, however, my main bitterness results in the cynical stripping of agency of women, that no matter what, we can't escape or ever achieve true liberation, that our forms of empowerment or expressions of femininity are wrongfully conceived in the post-feminist landscape.

Non-core politics

Last week during the walkout Viacom opted to suspend its programming on a number of its networks, including BET, Nickelodeon, and MTV.


There are a lot of different ways to read this, but I read it primarily as a mixture of these two:

  • Whoa, this is amazing! The folx in Parkland have been able to mobilize people in powerful ways — including media outlets that usually stay out of it.
  • Wow, Viacom has really leaned into progressive issue coverage as part of their business model.

The thing that I find most interesting about it, though, is the consideration of what messages were shown on different Viacom networks. MTV's image very clearly states what the issue is, where MTV stands, and is followed by a call to action for people to join. BET did something similar, but couched it in Viacom messaging rather than their own. And Nickelodeon, well, Nickelodeon played only on the idea that kids are leading the way and didn't actually say anything about what they're leading on.

I hesitate to dive too far into speculation about why each message was constructed the way it was, but there's a lot to be said about the differences that makes me think that while plenty of people at the network clearly care about the issue, there's a definite brand filtering that recalls Naomi Klein's work in No Logo. Brand Identity is set up as something to be consumed in particular ways, as progressive, as kids, or something else. And similarly, there seems to be an evolution from how Sarah Banet-Weiser talks about the move towards diversity being couched in "good business" language that distances the politics.

Thursday, March 15, 2018

"That's just, like, the rules of feminism!" - Core Post 4

Ambivalence and ambiguity seem to be some of the key characteristics of postfeminism that the week’s readings address. For Banet-Weiser, racial ambiguity in postfeminist popular culture serves to dilute the political significance of racial difference and instead promotes the image of a urban multicultural consumer-citizen whose primary articulation of race and gender are as commodities. For McRobbie, postfeminism draws upon feminist histories, but only does so in order to disavow feminism as history - a thing of the past. While McRobbie states that postfeminism seems to repudiate feminism (257), this repudiation also marks feminism’s post-mortem longevity and partial success. Butler also notes this ambivalence, nothing that postfeminism “simultaneously rejects feminist activism in favor of feminine consumption and celebrates the success of feminism while declaring its irrelevance” (44).

Post-feminism is a discursive formation, a “Gramscian common sense” (McRobbie 256), or a “sensibility” (Butler 45). In order for to have occurred, then, feminist values have to have been at least partially internalized into the dominant culture. For Butler, postfeminism is necessarily a neoliberal discursive formation that offers “a more attractive alternative to previous forms of gender politics.” Postfeminism takes on the characteristics of post-Fordist capital - it easily takes the shape of new political and social terrains. Looking at the 6 characteristics of postfeminism Butler lists, half of them could be said to be characteristics of a neoliberal economy.

I do have several questions regarding the readings: While there are still young women who dismiss the idea of being a feminist, it is easy to observe how the meaning has transformed again. Butler’s line that “postfeminism requires is that women ‘be who they want to be” — just as long as it is not a feminist” (44) does not seem accurate any longer. How has the postfeminist landscape and popular media changed in the past decade or so?

While I think Butler’s argument that marginalized subjects are still interpolated by postfeminism even if it privileges a white, heterosexual subject is correct, I am bit hesitant to agree with the notion that women of color can symbolically fracture the whiteness of postfeminism. While Butler notes that a figure like Nicki Minaj consciously plays with and breaks down her racial and gender identity in her music and style, are these fluid qualities not the very same qualities of a neoliberal postfeminism she observes earlier? If postfeminism is a discursive sensibility, then is it is possible for a figure like Minaj to enthusiastically play with gender and race at the same time as it is commodified? Doesn’t postfeminism take advantage of this very ambivalence in order to sell this process as empowerment? Or, maybe a better question is: does (postfeminist) media necessarily reify things like culture, race, and gender?