I am rewatching The Killing, which my wife had never seen, and I find myself just as sucked in the second time around. If you haven't seen it you can find it on Netflix. It is a detective murder mystery that is so detailed and attentive to the nuances of each of its characters that it progresses on an approximate ratio of 1 episode = just less than 1 day in the narrative. This may sound excruciating to some of you, but I promise that all four seasons are intensely satisfying and so compelling that even on the second viewing make me want to abandon my entire life to immediately binge watch the entire thing.
It also rains in virtually every scene which I find a calming reprieve to the oppressive and eternal heat of Los Angeles.
Monday, April 9, 2018
Core Post - Kumar is great and other jumbled thoughts...
There is so much that excited me about Kumar’s piece that I hardly know where to begin. Her anecdote about Derrida giving a lecture about a theory of titles as a middle finger to the administration was hilarious. Her salient genealogy of global television studies and the challenges of approaching it through standard academic disciplines was really impressive. And as others have noted, her conclusion was brilliant. And it is this paradox that she ends with that I would like to focus upon.
If global television studies is both necessary because of the pervasiveness of the rhetoric and economic practice of globalization and impossible because it will necessarily result in “unequal discourse”, then it requires of us a process-oriented methodology of intellectual examination. By this I mean that the Hegelian model of dialectical progress in thought, wherein one philosophical (or in Kumar’s terms disciplinary) mode clashes with another and through that collision subsumes much of the old mode into a new synthesis. I take Kumar to be rejecting the universalizing nature of this model and accepting that there is no universal progression of thought without a colonial power dynamic taking place, and therefore is advocating a world wherein a diversity of perspectives can exist side by side along one another, without needing to be fit into a neat “interdisciplinary” universal. This is something that I have been thinking a lot about myself, and feel vindicated to see it in this essay (assuming I am not misreading her argument).
Another theoretical possibility of this process-oriented methodology is an inversion of values whereby the means is more valuable than the end, precisely because there is no longer the possibility of an end for an end will necessarily result it breaking down, as Kumar put it. This may be another way of phrasing the rejection of a universal, but I think it is worth stating again, for if the ends can no longer justify the means, then perhaps we can rethink the dominant academic reification of competition and dialectical struggle. This doesn’t mean an end to it so much as and ethical rewiring that might mean a change in the way universities and research initiatives are funded antagonistically, which seems to me to harken back to this classical Humanist methodology. I realize that these thoughts might not make sense to anyone but me; I am writing them because they have been on my mind for months and this is the first excuse I’ve had to give them voice, so please forgive the rawness of my half-formed thoughts.
One of the reasons why I find this approach so exciting is that it allows scholars to be wrong and for their wrongness to be generative and progressive, or as Kumar puts it “where, paradoxically, it breaks down.” It may be that scholarship from an Anglo-American perspective comes to conclusions about global television, that from another perspective, say an East-Asian feminist perspective is wrong on some accounts, and vice versa, but because we can hold the impossibility of a universal account of globalization both accounts are generative as long as they are done in good faith by “extending the discipline to its dialogical limits.” It seems to me that some of the fierce debates between scholars who should be natural allies, here I’m specifically thing of post-Marxist and feminists, could perhaps be less self-righteous and more collegial. But then again maybe I’m wrong, nevertheless isn’t that ok in this brave new world?
If global television studies is both necessary because of the pervasiveness of the rhetoric and economic practice of globalization and impossible because it will necessarily result in “unequal discourse”, then it requires of us a process-oriented methodology of intellectual examination. By this I mean that the Hegelian model of dialectical progress in thought, wherein one philosophical (or in Kumar’s terms disciplinary) mode clashes with another and through that collision subsumes much of the old mode into a new synthesis. I take Kumar to be rejecting the universalizing nature of this model and accepting that there is no universal progression of thought without a colonial power dynamic taking place, and therefore is advocating a world wherein a diversity of perspectives can exist side by side along one another, without needing to be fit into a neat “interdisciplinary” universal. This is something that I have been thinking a lot about myself, and feel vindicated to see it in this essay (assuming I am not misreading her argument).
Another theoretical possibility of this process-oriented methodology is an inversion of values whereby the means is more valuable than the end, precisely because there is no longer the possibility of an end for an end will necessarily result it breaking down, as Kumar put it. This may be another way of phrasing the rejection of a universal, but I think it is worth stating again, for if the ends can no longer justify the means, then perhaps we can rethink the dominant academic reification of competition and dialectical struggle. This doesn’t mean an end to it so much as and ethical rewiring that might mean a change in the way universities and research initiatives are funded antagonistically, which seems to me to harken back to this classical Humanist methodology. I realize that these thoughts might not make sense to anyone but me; I am writing them because they have been on my mind for months and this is the first excuse I’ve had to give them voice, so please forgive the rawness of my half-formed thoughts.
One of the reasons why I find this approach so exciting is that it allows scholars to be wrong and for their wrongness to be generative and progressive, or as Kumar puts it “where, paradoxically, it breaks down.” It may be that scholarship from an Anglo-American perspective comes to conclusions about global television, that from another perspective, say an East-Asian feminist perspective is wrong on some accounts, and vice versa, but because we can hold the impossibility of a universal account of globalization both accounts are generative as long as they are done in good faith by “extending the discipline to its dialogical limits.” It seems to me that some of the fierce debates between scholars who should be natural allies, here I’m specifically thing of post-Marxist and feminists, could perhaps be less self-righteous and more collegial. But then again maybe I’m wrong, nevertheless isn’t that ok in this brave new world?
Core Post, Week 14
Curtin’s piece highlights the particular ways in which
globalization does not necessarily mean an “imperialist media” at work but rather
a complex dynamic that occurs via sociological, political and economic affordances.
I found this piece thorough in understanding the logistics behind media
produced within a global system. Curtin cites three principles of “media
capital” that aid in the structuring of cinema and broadcasting: a logic of
accumulation, trajectories of creative migration and forces of sociocultural
variation. While otherwise understood superficially, these principles lay out
the incremental ways capital plays into global media.
What I find interesting is the output that we receive in
understanding a ‘global’ platform. In particular, the ways in which international
news and television shows are broadcast stateside. With the proliferation of
cable during the late twentieth century, international news is readily
available, as opposed to public broadcasting that allocated specific hours for ‘global’
news programs. Subsequently, the role digital platforms have assumed garner the
potential for consumption. Presently, satellite or subscription services like
Murdoch’s Star counter with platforms like YouTube.
I find Curtin’s initial discussion of an “imperialist media”
useful in further arguing his conclusion in favor of culturally apt media that
can “foster identity, enhance social cohesion, serve local businesses, enhance
property values, and provide spaces for public discourse.” Introducing
particular television shows within a culture works both ideologically and
politically. We can see an active example of this during the Vietnam War when American
television programs, previously unavailable, were introduced to incite cultural
values. In the same way this polarizing argument frames imperialist media as a
benefit Hollywood film might come to inspire on a region, media was precisely
used as a political tool for the indigenous population. In this lens, the
implementation of media capital is a direct tool in promotion of imperialist
ideology.
What happens after the discipline breaks? - Core Post 5 - Josh
We don’t know what will occur after
the break; nonetheless, this is the target we ought to aim for, a target that
should break. As Shanti Kumar concludes, “Therefore, within the university
system practitioners of television studies may need to shed all pretensions of
being ‘interdisciplinary,’ and engage with its disciplinarity by extending the
discipline to its dialogical limits where, paradoxically, it breaks down”
(151). This is Kumar’s solution, I think, to the double bind that is Global
Television Studies; the double bind being the impossibility and necessity of
studying television in a global framework. We certainly must take a global approach
to T.V. studies, and to ‘study’ itself more generally, but a truly global, interdisciplinary
approach is impossible for all the reasons Kumar lays out.
This is
quite a different approach from David Morely’s investment in empirical knowledge
of television reception and from Michael Curtin’s genealogy of media capital.
Yet, I don’t think Kumar is in disagreement necessarily with Morley and Curtin.
It seems, instead, that Kumar is arguing for self-reflexivity in the terrain of
Global T.V. Studies, or an awareness that while the discipline is useful, it is
also impotent.
This
perhaps explains my gripe with industry studies last week, as I find that the
accumulation of empirical evidence and the disciplines that espouse that
approach are useless so long as they ignore questions of how academic inquiry
is itself imbricated and enabled by structures of power, both global and local
(though they might, in another sense, be useful to capital). Though it is obvious,
it is perhaps not said often enough that where ideas come from, and how they
are produced and distributed, makes a significant difference in the shape those
ideas take. We might think back to McLuhan’s “the medium is the message,” and ask
ourselves if the academy is not itself a medium that both produces and distorts
our messages.
As a
concluding thought, I’d like to pose the question of what differentiates
interdisciplinarity from lateral or horizontal thinking. The difference might
be in the end towards which our intellectual questions bring us. Both disciplinarity
and interdisciplinarity operate according to a “pursuit” of knowledge, or even
the pursuit of a break, as in Kumar’s case. I would argue that lateral/horizontal
thinking is not about a unilateral pursuit (pursuit, I think, is always
illusory), but something more like a return – a return to what is already “known”
– such that we are invested in finding new questions for old answers. We might,
then, already be living in the ruins of our disciplines, or the awareness that
they will not lead us to satisfying solutions or conclusions. How then do we
make do with these ruins? If these ruins are broken solutions, how might we
live with questions and no answers?
You guys, Jennifer Holt is REALLY NICE!
So, remember how I mentioned that there was an invitation-only even on Thursday were she'd be speaking? I went and there she was, the only woman in a 4-person panel that was supposed to have a conversation on the histories of technological rupture. She talked about what we talked about in class, vertical integration and content production, particularly comparing new media (such as Netflix) vs. Hollywood studios. She said that the battle now is in the control of the wires, because no matter how ethereal we think the internet is, if you want to stream something on Netflix, you have to plug at least one thing. Therefore, her future work entails even more analysis on the infrastructure of entertainment.
After the panel, I talked to her and discovered that she's really pretty cool and easy to talk to. I told her that we had just read her earlier stuff on class - oh and by the way, Prof., she sends her love - and I asked her if her work resonated well with policy makers (remember how we talked about her work lacking some more theoretical fierceness a la McChesney?). By the end of the conversation, she hugged me goodbye!!!!!! #girlpower (<-- yeah, yeah, I know it's problematic, whatevs)
After the panel, I talked to her and discovered that she's really pretty cool and easy to talk to. I told her that we had just read her earlier stuff on class - oh and by the way, Prof., she sends her love - and I asked her if her work resonated well with policy makers (remember how we talked about her work lacking some more theoretical fierceness a la McChesney?). By the end of the conversation, she hugged me goodbye!!!!!! #girlpower (<-- yeah, yeah, I know it's problematic, whatevs)
Core post — complexity and ritual
There's a very clear unifying thread this week about the complexity of considering television (and really, any media) studies at the global level. Each of the articles takes a slightly different tack in discussing it. Kumar's discussion includes a pedagogical framework for highlighting that complexity through a continual exploration of the paucity of any definition, which has done a great job structuring our class thus far and really does show how the paucity goes both ways, towards field and object. Curtin I think frames the complexity most simply: it's not about seeing the forest and the trees, but rather taking both into account together. And while both of those articles made their own interesting points, I was the most interested by Morley's article this week because I've spent much of the semester thinking about the ritual aspects of television.
James Carey describes it by way of example with the newspaper. "A ritual view of communication will...view reading a newspaper less as sending or gaining information and more as attending a mass, a situation in which nothing new is learned but in which a particular view of the world is portrayed and confirmed." I tend to agree with the idea not that the view is correct, but rather that it's an important aspect of our communicative practices that is often pushed aside in favor of considering almost exclusively what information is being presented and/or how the audience is reading a text. One particular set of texts that brought it to mind earlier in class was the screenings of Life with Luigi, when we were discussing the ways that the text served as instruction to viewers — in addition to the information gleaned (or not), there's a particular way that watching it means acting/becoming/being part of the community that is considering what it means to integrate. Participation comes not only through opening a line of credit, but also through the act of watching (without any valuation of that participation). Morley seems to take it into account really intelligently to me, asking how the "we-feeling" of community is continually engendered, and holding together the ways that television and similar communication technologies are able to simultaneously fragment and homogenize cultures — "the regular viewing of television news (or of a long-running soap opera) can be seen in the same light - as discourses which constitute collectivities through a sense of 'participation' and and through the production of both a simultaneity of experience and a sense of a 'past in common.'"
That sort of nuance and holding of contradiction is, to me, the most difficult and interesting part of high-quality writing because it creates space for questions and further research that promises to hold both the forest and the trees in view. Rather than speculating about homogenization in general, the question becomes for which groups is there a sense of homogenization, for which is there a sense of fragmenting, and in relation to which media and where? Of course, that kind of nuance and specificity is difficult — especially in the face of a question like, "so what?" But, frankly, I think some of the reason that arguments get overextended and don't navigate or investigate a contradiction without resolving it is because the drive to have a big, bold, "so what" gets in the way.
James Carey describes it by way of example with the newspaper. "A ritual view of communication will...view reading a newspaper less as sending or gaining information and more as attending a mass, a situation in which nothing new is learned but in which a particular view of the world is portrayed and confirmed." I tend to agree with the idea not that the view is correct, but rather that it's an important aspect of our communicative practices that is often pushed aside in favor of considering almost exclusively what information is being presented and/or how the audience is reading a text. One particular set of texts that brought it to mind earlier in class was the screenings of Life with Luigi, when we were discussing the ways that the text served as instruction to viewers — in addition to the information gleaned (or not), there's a particular way that watching it means acting/becoming/being part of the community that is considering what it means to integrate. Participation comes not only through opening a line of credit, but also through the act of watching (without any valuation of that participation). Morley seems to take it into account really intelligently to me, asking how the "we-feeling" of community is continually engendered, and holding together the ways that television and similar communication technologies are able to simultaneously fragment and homogenize cultures — "the regular viewing of television news (or of a long-running soap opera) can be seen in the same light - as discourses which constitute collectivities through a sense of 'participation' and and through the production of both a simultaneity of experience and a sense of a 'past in common.'"
That sort of nuance and holding of contradiction is, to me, the most difficult and interesting part of high-quality writing because it creates space for questions and further research that promises to hold both the forest and the trees in view. Rather than speculating about homogenization in general, the question becomes for which groups is there a sense of homogenization, for which is there a sense of fragmenting, and in relation to which media and where? Of course, that kind of nuance and specificity is difficult — especially in the face of a question like, "so what?" But, frankly, I think some of the reason that arguments get overextended and don't navigate or investigate a contradiction without resolving it is because the drive to have a big, bold, "so what" gets in the way.
Saturday, April 7, 2018
Core Post 5 - LeMaire
This week, I was especially drawn to Kumar’s closing
discussion, in which he calls for a deconstructionist approach to “global television
studies”—and more broadly, any academic “discipline”—in order to validate the
notion that scholars can and should be both disciples and critics of his or her
respective disciplines. He presents a familiar version of what this could look
like in the classroom, arguing that classes should focus on a dialogical
strategy “รก la Derrida,” in which any given discipline is treated as a “signifier”
which has innumerable functions and limitations (150). Here, I was reminded of
our first meeting, when we were asked to define TV, an impossible task that has
since established a theme throughout our course. I believe that by aligning with
this strategy, rather than any particular set of disciplinary practices, we have
been able to approach each week’s reading with a healthy amount of skepticism. Last
week, for example, turned out to be a controversial set of readings because of
our immediate attention to two of the authors, who more blatantly align with a particularly
narrow view of TV (i.e. a socio-political industrial history). Kumar, citing
Derrida, calls for scholarship that always exists “at the limits of disciplinarily
in the modern university and in modernity at large” (151). Thus, we experienced
the reverse of our observation about industry studies scholars during our week
on TV & Genre, when it became apparent that the scholars were situating
themselves at the boundaries of cultural studies (i.e. Jane Feuer’s and Jason
Mittell’s surprising attention to textual readings).
For Kumar, the real motive for deconstruction is to draw scholars’
attention to the “incommensurability” of any given discourse, particularly in
relation to Western-Eastern discourse. I had never before really considered Western
theory’s hierarchical dominance over Eastern scholarship. In true deconstructionist fashion, Kumar finds that even our attempts to generate a discourse
about hierarchical structures in global media is itself an act of cultural
dominance: “any global discussion of television in the current geopolitics of
international communication necessarily means an unequal discourse” (151). This
is not to say that we should abandon our disciplines, but rather examine its
limitations, which for me, has been a big part of this class, and works as a
fitting concluding thought, as our meetings begin to come to an end.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)