Saturday, April 7, 2018

What we're working on...

While I'm #grateful that we were given the opportunity to choose to dodge presentations, I am nonetheless interested in what people are working on--I personally find it hard to go through a class without having a sense of how people are ultimately engaging with the work, where the class has taken them, etc.

Maybe folks could post in a word or sentence, however specific or vague, what project you're working on, or what approach you're taking, or whatever seems to satisfy the request to you, should you take it up.

I'm thinking against the implementation of video visitation programs and infrastructure at U.S. jails and prisons.

Friday, April 6, 2018

Negotiating the Local and the Global through Media (Core Post 5)

I want to focus specifically on the Morley article from this week. Morley attempts to understand the whole through studying the sum of its parts. In the first part of his essay, Morley focuses on some studies of the global and the local in terms of studying technology consumption. Morley then shifts to negotiate the postmodern media landscape paradox of individual media consumption and the formation of homogenized identities or social groupings.

Morley attempts to negotiate understanding the macro processes of media through localized consumption of media. Much of his article reads as a defense of his ethnographic research methodology of being in the living rooms of UK families, studying which programs gather the family around the living room TV, which programs people watch simultaneously yet in different rooms, and which the varied programs based on gender, age, class, etc. For Morley, in the realm of audience studies, there exists a central tension, that between "romanticism of 'consumer freedoms'" of the consumers and the "paranoiac fantasy of 'global control'" of the producers (1). For Morley, it perhaps is no longer a question of encoding and decoding in terms of media institutions and this monolithic power that these institutions have to influence and program audiences who must actively decode such insidious mechanisms of control. To Morley, traditions of audience studies, optimistic of audience agency, neglect serious questions of power and manipulation. Furthermore, it is not enough the simply conclude that consumers can be creative in the ways in which they receive media (read as: the ways in which they can counter dominant discourse). Morley defends his method by stating that his studies extend beyond this "banal" observation by examining the ways in which these creative abilities manifest in terms of access and "appropriate" usage (4). In order to understand issues of access, and when access is achieved, issues of usage (consumption) and then connect these issues to our understanding of macro processes of media production, distribution, and consumption, we must start from the bottom up, the living room, rather than rely on reductive technological determinism. For example, Morley argues that in order for new media technologies to be adapted and widely used, they must somehow overlay old patterns of consumption or must work on some basic understanding (9). Think, for example, of the slow process of the introduction of the iPhone, testing user adaptation through the iPod touch.

Moving on from discussions of how best to study the relationship between media products and consumers, Morley engages in questions of the future as media becomes more essential and routine to daily postmodern life. For example, while media technology has now become, more or less, omnipresent in affluent countries, this homogenizing effect has led to even further fragmentation: narrowcasting TV channels, the telephone undermining spatially contingent communities as distance no longer poses a threat to a sense of place and acceptance, and his predictive gap between the info-rich and the info-poor as media technology add-ons require a certain level of income. Technologies are no longer public resources once they are ingrained enough to provide this crucial foundation upon which to overlay new advances to core technologies (cable to TV, streaming to the computer/TV, the cell phone to the landline). In this regard, I am thinking of the forced banishment of analog televisions of yesteryear (at least something they did in Florida several years ago) which put a significant amount of senior citizens with limited income in a do-or-die position to upgrade their televisions and televisual access. Literally, the public open access of a satellite was taken away for more private televisual access. He's not too far off in terms of the telephone eliminating spatial barrier if we look at social media. Why make friends in a new place when I have easy access to my friends back home or my friends across the country? I can text, call, videochat with them when I'm lonely and miss their voice or want to see how their looks have changed. Even more, why even call them when I can read their incessant Facebook updates, Instagram posts, or tweets?

On the flipside, Morley analyzing fragmented consumption that can lead to homogenization. He specifically analyzes how local news can reinforce ideas of community and nation. The individual, through the "we-feeling" promoted by news (stories that affect us all or that we should know to remain informed), begins to identify with this "we" be it the nation, municipality, etc. As technological overlays have transformed the ways in which news is presented (we no longer just watch Walter Cronkite somberly deliver us the news), Morley engages with the postmodern obfuscation of reporting or performing (13). This engagement reminded me of the news clips we watched in this week's lecture: the fancy graphics, the simulcasts, live reporting of "major" events, the split screens, etc. Rather than simply telling us what happened, TV now tries to embroil us in the event.

Side note of some things that I was confused about: Morley mentions at least twice in the article the gender roles entrenched in certain technologies but fails to go into greater detail, which peeved me. He also mentions some sort of invocation of sociology as a necessary precondition to meaningful studies of TV and media but doesn't wholly define those parameters of methodologies.


Non-core Post - The Americans


I hope I'm not stealing your thunder here, Sasha (I keep checking to see if you’ve posted your draft about The Americans). I’m just too eager to jumpstart a discussion about the new season with you and those who are following (anyone else??). The first episode already blew me away and reminded me why it's my favorite show still airing. Everything about it is so understated and counter to the normal TV drama formula. What I was most impressed with about the premier is the utter lack of dialogue. It’s often been said that the wordless montage against the perfect 80s song is the show’s ultimate signature, and it’s never been truer here. As the stakes get higher, the words between characters become fewer and farther apart, and for me, it’s both hypnotic and deeply unsettling.

Thoughts? I haven’t had the chance to watch the new episode yet, but I plan to over the weekend.
                                                                                                              

Tuesday, April 3, 2018

Non-core post on Sinclair Broadcast Group

Here is also a link of another news piece on Sinclair Broadcast Group. He goes into a little more depth of what is at stake for these anchors if they decide to not go with what is required by SBG.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZ5S95GUtiI

Non-core post on Fan Games

As I mentioned in class here is a video that discusses the change in the way that legislation looks at video games' intellectual property. Yes, it's a little weird, but this is a channel created by a guy who knows his stuff when he talks about gaming and YouTube as a business. Also the more Theorists I can convert the better.
 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TiYEKDQZ5sk

Jelena Core Post

Jelena Culibrk

Buffy the Vampire Slayer is a fine example of the changes brought onto the media landscape in the 1990s with numerous institutional, political, cultural and economic changes. Most annoyingly, for my respective colleagues and myself, the intergretion of the the musical into the series was painful. Hybridisation of genre is naturally present in Buffy, and relates to Caldwell’s notion of the “assemblage.” Namely, divergent forms of “content” (not anymore monolithic “programmes”) are brought in together to address and cater to the widest possible audience. Both domestic and overseas. Yet, I cannot help but notice that the most annoying aspect of Buffy—the musical—was the most formalistically potent one for it allowed, probably what would otherwise be a censored aspect, representation of young female sexuality (more conrectely, orgasm through the musical scene in which Tara is lifted from the bed whilst singing). Moreover, Buffy is also rembered for its pioneering representation, and controversial (due to it’s abrupt ending), of a teenage lesbian relationship. From Caldwell’s piece, we can assume that these are all formalistic changes that were brought on by “the promise of diversity.” Namely, 1990s television brought these myriad forms of content to the audiences. However, Caldwell and Jenkins view these as not neutral technological achievements. While Jenkins understands the change as insidious (for the paradoxical interplay between “freedom of choice,” and the content-monopoly), Caldwell is interested in explaining how content amlgamation displayed not only the changing relationships of television to the internet, previously seen (or topically seen) as antithetical, but also television’s unique resilience. The change Caldwell goes against the grain by posing that “new media” (i.e., the internet) brought on interactivity. For Caldwell, interactivity was/is central to television.

Interactivity, according to Caldwell, was always economically feasable from television’s beginnings in the 1940s. Indeed, interactivity can be seen as a form of extended public sphere that texts create when they are consumed by either its critiques or vehement supporters. I suppose this 1 of 4 comes from the capitalist notion that any publicity is good, given that the system is presupposed on heightening the levels of production AND consumption. Particularly in the neoliberal version of capitalist logic, production ceases to be the most important aspect of a company’s mission, but rather the perpetuation of “brands.” This we know from popular sources like Naomi Klein’s No Logo published around the time (circa 2000), according to Caldwell, television and internet have extended their cooperation. Hence, there is certainly a relationship between television and neoliberal logic, as we have seen on the most blatant example of the Regan-era Dynasty. However, we can find this connection in Caldwell’s nuanced examples. Neoliberalism [I would also add the destruction of the two political blocs, and the notion of “a historical end,” alla Fukuyama], lax on syndication laws in 1990s, cable television, and new modes of television interactivity are all part of the same interactive-logic that is deeply tied into aggressive capital production. Unlike the cinema, television was incredibly resilient to the threats posed by interactivity. Moreover, it welcomed it. [One only needs to think about the pitiful and rare 2000s efforts to produce an interactive film. I was at such a screening. William Castle with his late-1950s scent-cards was innovative in contrast to these cinema productions.] However, the Caldwell piece left me methodologically unsatisfied by its lack of clear flag-posting.

While reading John Caldwell’s piece, particularly the question: “What if a broadband network had already been in place?” apropos of the relationship of television to the internet is interesting, albeit not as revolutionary as I would expect from this informative, oft-times informationoverloaded article. More conrecetly, I critique Caldwell’s “eureka” moment with historiographic questions that have been in circulation for at least the last three decades. [Most predominantly with the establishment of my much-beloved journal Representations.] I cannot say with certainty that this is due to the two disciplines—historiography, and media studies at a particular moment—lack of dialogue. Indeed, media studies have undergone a tremendous shift from the much-crticised form-obsessed analysis (i.e., close-analysis of media texts) to contextualisation—historic, socio2 of 4 economic, political etc. I am also aware that Caldwell’s goal in this piece is not to entertain with historiographical questions, but rather to show the adaptibility, flexibility, and resilience of television to the threats of “new media.” However, Caldwell rightly reaches the eureka moment— how “new” is the new? Lisa Gitelman has given us great piece on the development and relience of “new media” to 18th century ones. Yet, early modern historians, particularly those that are concerned with the history of the book (which is an odd little discipline, or perhaps a historical attitude. I am yet to find out.) are doing tremendous work in chipping away “the modernity” argument that has tarnished media studies for far-too long. [My own intellectual development has, until recently, entirely depended on 1990s/early 2000s works on modernity.] Interestingly, even Buffy incites an interest in the relationship between the printed book, and modern media. Shots of old manuscripts, and rare books dominate the series. Moreover, they invite or preclude Western culture’s newly-resurrected interest in “intellectual fiction” (for the sake of not knowing how to find the better word to name massive teenage media content like Harry Potter that privilege the atmosphere of learning, curiosity, friendship, and fun.) There is much to be told about the relationship between television and the book as an older, pre-VCR form of a “programmes” afterlife. I am thinking here about the BBC personal documentaries of the late-1960s and early 1970s. Not only did books, as a condensed version of the shows, function as an extended after-life but also as pragmatic tools that changed intellectual histories of many future American scholars. [I am going to heavily criticise the BBC’s Eurocentricism in my presentation next week, but there is also much to be praised in the cultural changes these shows brought. Not least a new mode of visual historiography.]

Perhaps my frustration with Caldwell stems from the fact that I am looking for a more clear “wink” at the way knowledge is being influenced by these changing socio-political landscapes, otherwise exceptionally analysed by Caldwell. I want intellectual history under convergance media. Yet, how much can an academic article do? There certainly are forms of restraint, either imposed by 3 of 4 the discipline, publisher, or the author herself/himself. Is actually Jenkins’ analysis of “knowledge culture” the wink much-needed?

Monday, April 2, 2018

Core Post #5: Are fans of Reality TV ‘industrial actors’? (Phil Miller)

While reading Caldwell, I found his analysis of television’s historical responses to technological advancement quite relevant in present day entertainment.  Especially, since there has been a surge of the television industry utilizing the internet to either capitalize with the intent of profitability or comprehend audience responses to certain episodes or story arcs, the internet is in not doubt converging with television.  This harks back to earlier discussion in the semester of where not only, ‘what is TV?’ but also ‘Where is TV?’ especially since convergence is become quite prominent.  

This discussion has made me think of the modes that this is embodied within reality TV, but especially one of my own personal favorite shows: RuPaul’s Drag Race.  I know I continue to refer back to this show, but I can’t help it because it provides a plethora of analysis and examples.  The internet has continued to play such a vital role of the impact and malleability of the show itself.  I think this visceral impact has complicated the term of ‘industrial actors.’  Caldwell states that “programs on TV are not simply authored ‘texts,’ they are also created by ‘industrial actors’ and choreographed through tried-and-proven modes on institutional interaction” (57).  The reason I think convergence has trivialized the this term is because of a controversial episode during season 6.  During one of the episodes, a mini-challenge took place that asked the contestants to identify people as ‘Female or She-Male’ by studying photos of people’s crotches.

The backlash, claiming that it perpetuated transphobia, resulted in the producers to completely change elements of the show in order to correct the error while also releasing a statement of apology.  This response by the fans and fixed by the producers (even at the behest of RuPaul who literally displayed a tantrum on Twitter as a result of the change) illustrates that “such sites suggest that criticism and analysis-even when negative and internalized-help fuel the entertainment machine” (53).  This change in structure even bled into the what I call the ‘sister-equivalent’ of the show called Untucked in the following season.  This additional program shows the queens backstage interacting while the judges continue to deliberate.  This show went from a very staged format to an almost verite type of form basically becoming what Caldwell calls the ‘making of’ stunt.  I would say this change in format is a result of one of the function of ‘stunts’ commonly used by television illustrated by Caldwell.  He writes “stunts allow members of both the audience and the production culture to articulate, revise, and rearticulate cross-industry relations” (64).  In conclusion, I think RuPaul’s Drag Race demonstrates as a perfect example of where TV is not only converging with the Web, but also how both seemingly different industries are now almost reliant and dialogical with each other.  

Work Cited 

Caldwell, John.  "Convergence Television: Aggregating Form and Repurposing Content in the Culture of Conglomeration."  Television After TV: Essays on a Medium in Transition, edited by Jan Olsson and Lynn Spigel, Duke University Press, 2004, pp. 41-74.